The Real Problem

Why would anyone want to see 34 nearly identical insurance options on their phone?"

This was my first question when I joined the team. The car insurance website had an 80% abandonment rate on the results page. Users saw 34 nearly identical options on mobile screens and left. It was obvious something was wrong, but nobody knew exactly what.

5. Test: Iterative Validation
  • 10 users tested navigation: successful
  • Qualitative feedback revealed need to improve copy
  • A/B testing validated each change before implementation
Learnings
  • Service Design reveals hidden problems: Mapping the entire journey showed internal competition between channels Objective frameworks accelerate decisions: RICE eliminated subjective discussions
  • Fewer options = more conversions: Hick's Law was confirmed in insurance Multifaceted research is key: Combining quantitative and qualitative methods revealed unique insights